hitcounter
This site is an rss/xml news reader containing our favorite feeds. All articles are the copyrighted material of the blogs that wrote them.

Finance 6.0 released

Yenco has released Finance 6.0, its banking software that provides tools for keeping track of bank a...



Read The Full Article:
http://feeds.macnn.com/click.phdo?i=3e96c7dd6f78b27712c5d3764f40b19f


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

remote-control system

Thinkflood has announced an app for the iPhone and iPod touch that works with the company's RedEye, ...



Read The Full Article:
http://feeds.macnn.com/click.phdo?i=876daf63c6b8d0a6735a398c94e264e1


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

More on Palms WebOS Media Sync

In yesterday’s piece on Palm’s WebOS “media sync” iTunes integration I mostly avoided the legal aspects. When I say that the WebOS media sync feature is not “legit”, I mean that it is not supported by Apple, not something Apple intends for third-parties to do, and (if Jon Lech Johansen’s theory is correct) a violation of the USB specification.

But is it illegal? And would it be illegal for Apple to take countermeasures against it? My guess is “no” to both questions.

WebOS’s media sync is clearly a hack, but hacks generally don’t violate any laws. I’m not a lawyer and I’m not an expert on the DMCA, but I don’t see how masquerading as an Apple iPod over USB would violate it. If Palm were doing something to strip DRM from music or video files, that would be another story. But they’re not.

Legality aside, is Palm doing anything wrong in a moral sense? Matthew Paul Thomas, on Twitter here and here, draws the analogy between WebOS masquerading as an iPod via USB and Safari masquerading as “Gecko” via its HTTP user-agent string so as to identify itself as being compatible with certain poorly-coded web sites. That’s an interesting analogy, but there are differences, including that Safari’s complete user-agent string still uniquely and honestly identifies it as Safari. Safari and other WebKit-based browsers such as Chrome include the word “gecko” in their user-agent strings on the assumption that web sites that look for “gecko” in the UA string do so not because they’re trying to serve specific content only to actual Gecko-based browsers, but because they’re trying to serve specific content only to browsers with Gecko-like rendering features. I.e. when Safari or Chrome “just works” when rendering some web site that checks for “gecko” in the UA string, it is almost certainly in accordance with the intentions of whoever developed the web site. When the Pre “just works” with iTunes, it is not in accordance with Apple’s intentions. That’s not to say it is wrong, especially since in both cases — browser UA strings and Palm’s media sync — the primary purpose to do what the user wants. But it’s not a great analogy.

I don’t think WebOS’s media sync is a mistake on Palm’s part because it is wrong, I think it’s a mistake because it is risky and unnecessary.

I think where Palm is weakest, legally, is with regard to all of the former Apple engineers now working on the Pre and WebOS. Even if Palm could prove that no former Apple employees used their knowledge of Apple trade secrets to implement this feature, I don’t know whether Palm is in good enough financial shape to duke it out.1

The flip side is the question of whether Apple would risk legal trouble by shipping a future release of iTunes that blocks WebOS from syncing. On the surface, one might think that Apple can do whatever it wants with its own software. The question some are raising though, is whether Apple should be legally constrained from anti-competitive behavior as the holder of a monopoly.

Nick Forge writes:

It?s one thing for Apple not to facilitate syncing with 3rd-party (non-Apple) players, but another altogether to actively go out of their way to stop it happening. Can you imagine the fallout if Microsoft were to add code into the SMB protocol that blocked access to non-Microsoft systems?

Apple effectively monopolises the portable media player market, and if they resort to Microsoft-in-the-90s style tactics to hold on to that monopoly, they could find themselves on the wrong side of the U.S. Department of Justice.

I disagree with Forge that an analogy to Microsoft and SMB is apt. Being the clear the market leader doesn’t necessarily mean that Apple holds a monopoly, a term which has been thrown around far too loosely in the aftermath of Microsoft’s court cases in the U.S. and E.U.

What monopoly does Apple hold, specifically? A monopoly in “portable media players” wouldn’t seem relevant — it is iTunes, the Mac and Windows software, that WebOS interfaces with, not iPods. Does iTunes (not the store, but the desktop app) constitute a monopoly? I would say no, not even close.

Often overlooked is that Apple already provides a way for third-party software to access the contents of your iTunes library: the iTunes Music Library.xml file. The legit way for a third-party portable device to sync music and video with iTunes is for the device makers to write or license their own software to read the iTunes Music Library.xml file and copy the media from the library. That’s what Nokia Multimedia Transfer and RIM’s BlackBerry Media Sync do, and it’s what DoubleTwist provides for a wide variety of non-Apple portable devices, including the Pre. Yes, DoubleTwist is Jon Lech Johansen’s company,2 but that doesn’t render invalid his opinion that WebOS’s media sync is a hack.

What it comes down to is that third-party (i.e. non-Apple) devices and software already have legitimate access to the contents of your iTunes library. The XML file describes the audio and video files and your playlists. The media files themselves are stored out in the open as regular files inside the “iTunes Music” folder.

What they don’t have is legitimate access to iTunes’s built-in automatic “just plug in the device via USB and iTunes will see it” syncing. I don’t see that as the basis for government anti-trust action against Apple. Rather than write their own Mac and Windows software to recognize when a Pre is plugged in and sync media with the iTunes library, Palm is piggybacking on the software Apple wrote to support iPods.

Ultimately, my guess is that Apple won’t take any immediate action — technical or legal — against Palm. I think Apple will treat it more or less how they’ve treated iPhone jailbreaking.


  1. And, when judging the likelihood of Apple filing such a lawsuit, consider the perspective of a certain highly-competitive quasi-paranoid Apple founder and CEO who is famously sensitive to what he perceives as being “ripped off”. The one and only company to ship a product that successfully masquerades as an iPod via USB is the company whose engineering division is run by a former Apple senior VP and has hired a slew of former Apple engineers. 

  2. And a previous sponsor of this site. 



Read The Full Article:
http://daringfireball.net/2009/06/more_on_webos_media_sync


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

TAB Welcomes: Chris Ryan


Whoa! It's Chris!

Hey, everybody! I?d like to introduce myself as another blogger to join the talented team at TheAppleBlog. So here?s the quick rundown all about me.

I?ll be the first to admit, I?m a bit of a rebel (I left the Twitter bandwagon ages ago, sorry!) but I love all things Apple. Like some, having had a bit of Apple retail experience, I hope that my articles will provide a unique insight into what makes Apple ?think different.? I also enjoy getting my hands dirty when it comes to OS X, so be on the lookout for some specialized, but fun ?How To? articles. Other interests of mine include graphic design, video editing, web design, photography, and pop culture. In fact, I might as well confess that I am a bit of a science fiction ?enthusiast.?

For those who are curious about my Mac setup, it consists of a MacBook Pro 2.8GHz (the new unibody model) and matching 2.8GHz aluminum and glass iMac, both with 4GB of RAM. You never can have enough, can you? (Or perhaps I?m just really OCD and everything has to match.)

Outside of the tech world, I enjoy kayaking and a nice game of tennis. When I?m not enjoying the sun, I?m running a graphic design business. If you want to find out more about me and ?socially network,? feel free to check out my site here. Of course, it looks best if you are in Safari.

I love interacting with people, so please feel free to leave comments on any of my posts and I?ll follow up with additional thoughts and conversation.



Read The Full Article:
http://theappleblog.com/2009/06/02/tab-welcomes-chris-ryan/


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

Electronic payment lawsuit

Actus LLC, patent holding company based in Marshall, Texas, has sued Apple, Amazon, Ebay, Best Buy, ...



Read The Full Article:
http://feeds.macnn.com/click.phdo?i=3265a299806c26d0d8e3d69df3d94688


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

Crime Spree, Postino

Photo fx ($3) provides users with 26 different customizable photo filters and 27 different film look...



Read The Full Article:
http://feeds.macnn.com/click.phdo?i=dcd509f7fce6e8c100205aa5577d4292


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

New Canon DSLRs due in 09

Canon is rumored by a magazine to be getting set to release two new high-end professional DSLR camer...



Read The Full Article:
http://feeds.macnn.com/click.phdo?i=2d435446930c64865734859da70fa215


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

Qualcomm Draft N module

Qualcomm on Monday announced the upcoming launch of its 802.11n wireless local-area networking (WLAN...



Read The Full Article:
http://feeds.macnn.com/click.phdo?i=537102881fd413f6bfd416b6766c3369


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

1Password 2.0 update

Agile Web Solutions has released an update to its password management application for the iPhone and...



Read The Full Article:
http://feeds.macnn.com/click.phdo?i=88a63e38362ace657fe6e9baa1fdd017


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!

MEI Installs K4 at Award-Winning Texas Monthly

Managing Editor Inc. today announced that it has installed the vjoon K4 Publishing System at Texas Monthly magazine. The Austin, Texas-based publication recently won a 2009 National Magazine Award for General Excellence. Texas Monthly's K4 implementation includes licenses for the magazine's editorial, art and production staff. It will also be incorporating several add-on tools into the new workflow: K4 Web Editor for remote access to the database.

Read The Full Article:
http://prmac.com/release-id-5917.htm


Add to del.icio.us   Digg this   Post to Furl   Add to reddit   Add to myYahoo!
Apple Tattoo Photograph Courtesy of Gerard
Website designed by Bartosz Brzezinski
Powered by blogdig.net